Dieser Bereich kann Inhalte enthalten, die nicht für alle Nutzer geeignet sind. Dazu können unter anderem Texte, Medien oder Diskussionen gehören, die als beleidigend, extremistisch, gewaltbezogen oder anderweitig belastend empfunden werden. Wenn du solche Inhalte nicht sehen möchtest, nutze bitte die jeweiligen Filter- und Meldeoptionen der Plattform oder meide entsprechende Threads/Communities.
lol ok, you don’t grasp basic things about how art works, about how art is always in conversation with the context it arose from given the author’s life experiences and yet you are committed to this futile argument.
The Magic Mountain is one of the world’s great antifascist novels.
You have to be joking.
I have constantly pointed out that Mann had not yet experienced fascism. That would happen later.
You have to be joking the art can only be interpreted strictly in that linear fashion, by the same logic Mein Kampf is barely fascist.
Fascism brought nothing new to the table that The Magic Mountain hadn’t already dismantled with fervor.
You have no conception of the relationships between simultaneous polarized reactions to the same perceived existential questions that dominate public discourse, what a morbid, lifeless view of history…
https://www.marxists.org/archive/lukacs/works/1943/humanism-barbarism/ch05.htm
https://dainealmaclean.medium.com/how-the-cabinet-of-dr-73660400e5e3
https://engelsbergideas.com/notebook/thomas-manns-cathedrals-in-prose/
You have read your own sources, right?
The first one, from marxists.org is an article about the Germans and why they let the Nazis seize power. The The author attests that
And uses The Magic Mountain and Heinrich Mann’s novel The Loyal Subject as examples for the then current condition of Germany. At no point does it mention anything anti-fascist about either book by the way.
It tells us that Mann identified mental conditions, the dissatisfaction, moral disgust, inability to understand why.
These are themes the reviewer identifies in the book.
That the people thus affected are ripe to accept fascism, later when it eventually comes about, is the reviewers conclusion.
It is not something expressed in the book.
Further down, other works are discussed and they are specifically called “anti-fascist” unlike The Magic Mountain.
About Farewell by Johannes Becher it says:
It draws the parallel of both books being set before WWI and the distinction that only one of them is is inspired by the modern anti-fascist struggle. It is not Mann’s.
Your second quote mentions The Magic Mountain in the first line and is then entirely about The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari.
And the third one
Yes, we’ve been over this. He didn’t like them from the beginning. Certainly didn’t improve his opinion when they set up their fascist regime, years after 1924.
All the same arguments about the passage of time and when things happen, that I’ve made before.