Wherever I wander I wonder whether I’ll ever find a place to call home…

  • 8 Posts
  • 1.25K Comments
Joined 10 months ago
cake
Cake day: December 31st, 2025

help-circle







  • You’re so right about that. And it’s really sad and disappointing, but it’s true.

    You tell the people “we need to convert the grid to renewables or else we’re going to cause a mass extinction event which will likely result in the widespread destruction of human society, and almost certainly will cause enormous amounts of avoidable suffering” and they don’t care because I guess it seems too abstract and far off (it’s not that far off) or because the scale is too massive or too unprecedented for them to comprehend. Or because they’ve been brainwashed to believe it’s a hoax. Or conditioned to think it’s a lost cause and have already given up hope.

    But if you tell them “We need to convert the grid to renewables because they’re cheaper than fossil fuels” then suddenly people support it.

    And if that’s the messaging that works, it’s what we need to run with.

    And yeah I know shit is expensive and people are suffering. Ideally we’ll get a progressive trifecta in 2028 and solve everything in one go. If I could promise you that, I would, but I obviously can’t.

    Even if we get an establishment dem in 2028 though, as long as it’s not a Blue Dog or a Third Way then I think there’s a good chance they’ll push for climate action and renewable energy.

    That’s not the only thing that needs reform of course but I have a fucking headache so I’m not gonna list all the shit that we needed to be doing six fucking years ago if we wanted to save the world.







  • Why do you think a violent revolution would result in a worker-controlled socialist society? It seems it would just result in a society dominated by whoever controls the revolution, its resources, and distribution systems.

    And the thing you gloss over is that that’s precisely what tends to happen in so-called “communist” revolutions. I put communist in quotes because I know that’s not true communism. But Stalin and Mao were both authoritarian dictators who centralized resources under their personal control, maintained dominance and hierarchy through their personality cults, and caused millions of deaths and widespread suffering throughout the regions under their control. To say nothing of the surveillance states they used to maintain their hold on power.

    I agree that capitalism is going to inevitably crumble, especially now that it’s reached the point when it physically cannot continue to expand. However, by my view, violence and chaos are the path to barbarism.

    The purpose of building the welfare state and social safety nets now isn’t to pacify the masses to enable capitalism to continue. It’s to have those structures in place so that when capitalism does inevitably fall, we’ll already be able to organize ourselves civilly and distribute resources in such a way that everyone has what’s needful.

    The transition to socialism can and must occur. But it must happen through political means, or else all is lost. And to do so, first the welfare state must be in place.






  • Maybe this is our disconnect:

    You seem to be approaching this as if the goal is a USSR-like society, and so you argue that progressive politics won’t achieve that.

    I agree. They won’t. And I don’t want them to, either. I would say most people don’t want that.

    By the angle I’m approaching from, which is what I think the current zeitgeist is onboard with, is making incremental progress towards a system closer to the Nordic Model.

    There’s a reason Norway has the stereotype of being one of the best places in the world to live. They enjoy an excellent quality of life. If we can achieve that in the US, I can spend the rest of my life peacefully avoiding politics, only turning up to vote in each election so that we can maintain it.

    And I believe that’s possible with progressive politics. And I believe it’s impossible to achieve using violence.

    So that’s likely the source of our disagreement. I don’t want a USSR-like society. I don’t want bolsheviks to violently overthrow the civic order, plunging society into chaos so that they can reshape it into their own authoritarian wetdream.

    So if that’s your goal, then I stand as firmly against you as I stand against fascism. And even if I have to walk a razor’s edge to arrive safely at my destination, then my feet are gonna bleed, but I’m gonna keep fuckin walking. Because that’s the only way forward that doesn’t lead off a cliff.